• Navigator
  • Real Estate Development and Housing

If Apartments Are Sitting Empty, Why Do We Still Need More Housing?

October 12, 2026 Tom Dworetsky, AICP

A red sign reading "For Rent" sits in front of a new townhome developmentAfter several years of rapid rent growth and limited housing availability, many communities have seen a wave of new apartment construction. In some markets, vacancy rates have risen as those new units come online.

Nationally, the rental vacancy rate reached 7.3% in the second quarter of 2026, up from 6.6% two years earlier, according to the US Census Bureau. That rise reflects a rental market with more breathing room than it had during the unusually tight conditions of recent years.

At the same time, that can create an understandable question for local officials and residents: If apartments are sitting empty, why do we need to keep building more housing?

The answer comes down to what vacancy actually tells us about a housing market, and, just as importantly, what it does not. A higher vacancy rate can be an important sign that a market is becoming more balanced. It does not necessarily mean that a community has built too much housing, nor that its housing affordability challenges have been solved.

Vacancy Creates Choice

In an extremely tight housing market, nearly every available unit is occupied. That may sound efficient, but it leaves renters with few choices and gives landlords little reason to compete on price, amenities, or quality.

Adding housing changes that dynamic. As new apartments come online, renters have more options. Older properties may need to offer concessions (temporary incentives, such as free rent or reduced fees), hold rents steady, or make improvements to compete for tenants.

In this sense, rising vacancy following a period of new construction may be a sign that new housing supply is doing exactly what it is supposed to do: creating some breathing room in the market.

Research on large new apartment buildings has found that additional market-rate supply can reduce nearby rents compared with otherwise comparable areas, suggesting that the effect of new construction extends beyond the units themselves.

The more useful question is not simply whether the vacancy rate went up. It is where the vacancies are occurring and why.

Newly constructed properties often experience elevated vacancy while they lease up. Vacancy may also be concentrated in the highest-priced units, certain unit sizes, or particular locations, while older and more moderately priced apartments remain almost completely occupied.

There Is No Single Housing Market

Housing markets are segmented by price, location, size, tenure, age, and quality. A vacant $2,800-per-month apartment does little to directly address the needs of a household that can only afford $1,500 a month. Likewise, a market with hundreds of available studios and one-bedroom apartments may still have limited options for families seeking three bedrooms. A community with a higher apartment vacancy rate may simultaneously have extremely limited for-sale inventory.

For that reason, housing availability is not simply a matter of counting units. A housing analysis needs to consider which units are available, at what price, and to whom. An increase in vacancy at the upper end of the rental market is different from widespread vacancy across all segments of the market.

Housing Filters Through the Market

Most new market-rate housing is expensive. There is a straightforward reason for this: New construction is expensive. Land, labor, materials, financing, permitting, and infrastructure costs generally make it difficult to build new housing that rents at the lower end of the market without some form of public subsidy.

But that does not mean higher-priced new housing has no effect on affordability elsewhere. When a household moves into a newly constructed apartment, it typically leaves another unit behind. Another household can move into that unit, leaving another vacancy, and so on.

Research tracking these migration chains found that new market-rate construction can loosen housing conditions in lower- and middle-income neighborhoods within a relatively short period, even when lower-income households are not the initial occupants of the new units.

There is also a longer-term process at work. As buildings age and newer alternatives are built, older properties can become less desirable relative to the newest housing in the market. They may not have the newest finishes, amenities, layouts, or energy-efficient systems. Over time, they can become relatively less expensive. This process is generally referred to as filtering.

Filtering is not automatic, immediate, or sufficient on its own to address housing needs. In strong-demand markets, older units can remain expensive or be renovated and repositioned upward. HUD’s 2023 Worst Case Housing Needs report identifies both new construction and the filtering down of surplus or aging higher-rent units as mechanisms through which the supply of affordable housing can grow. Dedicated affordable housing programs remain essential for households whose incomes are too low to be served by the market.

Today’s New Housing Is Tomorrow’s Older Housing

This raises another problem with declaring that a community has “enough” housing based on current vacancy. A community does not just need enough housing for this year. It needs a housing stock that can continually evolve as its population, economy, and households change.

If housing production slows or stops for a decade because a recent construction wave temporarily increased vacancy rates, that community will eventually have very little housing from that period entering the middle-aged portion of its inventory. Put simply, you cannot have older, naturally lower-cost housing in the future without building new housing first.

Restricting new development can also interfere with the filtering process itself. When households with higher incomes have few new options, they compete for the best units in the existing housing stock. According to an article published by the Brookings Institution, investors may also find it more attractive to renovate and reposition older buildings when creating new supply is difficult, preventing those units from filtering down in price.

None of this means every community should build indefinitely without regard to demand. Housing markets can become oversupplied, and prolonged vacancy can create real financial and neighborhood challenges.

The appropriate response to rising vacancy is analysis, not simply stopping development.

What Vacancy Rates Don’t Tell Us

Rather than asking, “Do we have enough housing?” communities should ask:

  • Where is vacancy concentrated?
  • Are newly built properties still leasing up?
  • Which price points and unit types remain tight?
  • Are rents continuing to increase or beginning to stabilize?
  • Are concessions becoming more common?
  • What is in the development pipeline?
  • What types of households are expected to grow?
  • What housing types are still missing from the market?

The objective should not be zero vacancy. Nor should it simply be maximizing the number of housing units. The goal is to create and sustain a housing market with enough supply, variety, and turnover to give households meaningful choices while allowing the housing stock to evolve over time.

After years of severe housing shortages in many communities, a little more breathing room in the market may not be evidence that we have built too much. It may be evidence that the market is finally beginning to work.

Learn about our real estate development analytics and advisory services


About the Author

Tom Dworetsky, AICP, is Vice President and Director of Research at Camoin Associates. He earned a Master of City and Regional Planning from the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill and a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Boston University. As the leader of Camoin Associates’ data team, Tom is well-versed in a broad array of housing and economic data sources. He applies advanced methodologies for housing needs analysis to answer critical research questions and produce actionable insights. He has extensive experience conducting fiscal impact analyses of housing of all types and assessing their contributions to local government revenues and expenses. Tom uses a data-driven approach to address housing challenges in communities with unique market conditions, and he has a particular interest in strategies to increase housing affordability and availability while fostering economic resilience.